• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer

  • About
  • Support FAQ
  • Contact
  • Login
DeliriumsRealm Logo

DeliriumsRealm.com

Demonology, Fallen Angels, and the Philosophy of Good and Evil

  • What is Demonology?
  • Demon Database
    • American Demons
    • Asian/East Demons
    • European Demons
    • Judeo-Christian Demons
    • Modern Magick Demons
  • Demonology Course
  • My Account
    • Login
    • Reset Password
The Victory of Eucharistic Truth over Heresy - Peter Paul Rubens

Christian Heresies: What is Heresy?

When we look back over the course of history, there are many groups that claim to have held the correct view of Christianity.

The Victory of Eucharistic Truth over Heresy - Peter Paul Rubens
The Victory of Eucharistic Truth over Heresy - Peter Paul Rubens
When we look back over the course of history, there are many groups that claim to have held the correct view of Christianity. Some examples include early Gnostic sects of the first few centuries, groups like the Waldensian or Cathars of the 11th-12th centuries, reformists like Martin Luther and John Calvin, and even scientific intellectuals like Copernicus. I’ll be talking more about these people in later posts, for now, I want to spend a few minutes defining “orthodoxy” and “heresy.”

Problems of Orthodoxy and Heresy

From a historical perspective, “orthodoxy” and “heresy” go hand in hand. Often, there is a series of intense debates between two or more opposing or contradictory beliefs. The winners of such debates usually find their beliefs to become the “orthodox” beliefs while the losers’ beliefs end up becoming defined by the victors as “heretical.”

If we look at the origins of the words, orthodoxy comes from the Greek meaning “right belief” while heresy literally means “a choice.” Therefore, the orthodox is the set of beliefs considered to be right, while heretics are people who actively choose to believe the wrong beliefs.

Of course, both words soon become problematic – everyone believes their beliefs are correct. If they doubted their beliefs or thought they were wrong, they’d change them. The people of history are no different from modern people – if they believe in something passionately, they’ll swear up and down that they hold the orthodox belief and their opponents are wrong.

Historical Perspectives

So, historians take a different approach. They still use the terms “orthodoxy” and “heresy,” but use them without moral judgment. Orthodoxy doesn’t refer to the people that were doctrinally and spiritually correct. Instead, the term “orthodoxy” refers to the doctrines and beliefs that eventually became official dogma. On the other hand, heresy does not refer to the people who were doctrinally and spiritually incorrect – those who actively chose to believe the wrong beliefs. Instead, historians use heresy to refer to the doctrines and beliefs that didn’t make it into official dogma.

Again, I stress, there’s no sense of “right” and “wrong” here – when you’re looking at writings and texts from a historical perspective, you can’t know which belief is the “right” or “wrong” belief. Sure, of course, you’ll have your opinions, but there’s no way to prove one side was clearly right while the other side was clearly wrong.

This is an important distinction when we start looking at early groups that sprang up during Christianity’s formative years. We know of numerous movements, all calling themselves Christians and claiming to know divine truths, dating from the 1st-4th centuries. For some of these movements, we have primary sources – writings penned by these groups about their beliefs. For others, we have numerous writings by the early Church Fathers – a group of spokespeople whose beliefs eventually became the official dogma of the Church in the 4th century – that passionately refute these groups.

Formations of Orthodox Christianity

During the 4th century, the Council of Nicea came together to discuss and debate what should be the Orthodox beliefs and what books should make up the New Testament. Before this time, people didn’t have an official handbook of texts like we have the New Testament nor did they have access to all the books we know as the New Testament. In fact, many had other writings, which often claimed to have been penned by apostles and others close to Jesus, which never made it into the New Testament.

Before the 4th century, it doesn’t make sense to label Christian beliefs as orthodox or heretical, simply because at that time, people were still debating and discussing what to believe. Each group passionately felt they were Christian and had the correct Christian beliefs. However, there was no official stance on what everyone who called themselves Christian should believe, so it was impossible to point to a book or creed and say – hey, you’re wrong. Therefore, historians refer to the beliefs that would eventually become the dominant beliefs as “proto-orthodox.”

Later Heretical Beliefs

Of course, once the Church established its official dogma, heresy took on a different meaning. Now, heresy means that you hold a belief that goes against the official dogma of your own religion. For instance, during the Inquisition, Muslims and Jews couldn’t be considered Christian heretics because they weren’t claiming to be Christians. Only Christians could be considered heretics. And, the Church at this time was powerful enough to do something about those spreading heretical beliefs – after all, there’s no point in branding someone a heretic if you’re not going to try to stop those beliefs from spreading.

There are 5 main types of heretics:

  1. Church Reformers – These are people that think the Church needs adjust its beliefs and/or practices that is in some way beyond what the Church is willing to do. With Martin Luther, this involved selling indulgences, criticizing the role of the Pope, and translating the Bible into the vernacular so everyone could understand it.
  2. Eccentrics – Usually individuals that work alone and hold fringe and sometimes bizarre beliefs.
  3. Dualists – Those people that take the dualism between body and spirit to extremes. For instance, the Cathars taught that this world is evil – even created by the devil, not God – and that pious Christians must separate and purify themselves from it.
  4. Reactionaries – People that refuse to accept a new dogma of the Church – for instance, when the Vatican proclaimed that mass should be said in the vernacular rather than Latin in the 1960s, some people refused to change.
  5. Intellectuals – These include the scientific thinkers whose beliefs went against Church belief, like Copernicus.
Category: Biblical StudiesTag: Christian Origins, Christianity
Previous Post:The Nightmare by Henry Fuseli (1781)Sleep Paralysis: Demon Encounters and Terror in the Night
Next Post:What Do We Know About the Historical Jesus?Jesus - Vladimir Borovikovsky

Sidebar

Want to learn more about Demons and Fallen Angels in Judaism & Christianity?

Enroll now in the course: Fallen Angels, Demons & Satan in Judeo-Christian Traditions

Get Started Today

DeliriumsRealm.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.

About | Privacy | Term of Use | Contact

  • Demon Database
  • American Demons
  • Asian/East Demons
  • European Demons
  • Judeo-Christian Demons
  • Modern Magick Demons
  • Demonology Course
  • What is Demonology?
  • What is Evil?
  • Theodicy: Why We Suffer
  • What is Apocalypticism?
  • How To Study Religion
  • Movie Reviews
  • Book Reviews


This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 international license.

We use cookies to make sure you have the best experience on our website. OK?   Accept
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT